6 Best Pizza Places in McCall
Find great places to eat and dine on your Idaho visit!
McCall, Idaho, is one of the most scenic little towns in the mighty Rocky Mountains. Situated on the breathtaking Payette Lake shores, McCall speaks to the adventurous mountaineer within us all. After a long day of climbing mountains and swimming in alpine lakes, you’re going to be hungry, and what better way to unwind and fill up than with the American favorite, pizza!
This is your guide to the pizza pies around McCall, plus a few options for different cuisine!
Photo Credit: Hal Halladay
Growler’s is a family owned and family-oriented pizza grill, serving some of the best pizza in Idaho! Here, you can find unique pizzas, such as the taco pizza and the Big Growler. Both are amazing choices! This homey place has five flatscreen TVs to watch the game and a cozy wood-burning stove to keep you warm on those brisk Idaho evenings. Even sporting a drive-through, Growlers is easy to get your hands on.
There is something here for everyone. From fresh, never-frozen burgers to the largest salad bar in McCall to a delicious selection of breakfasts, Growlers is a true one-stop shop for everything you need to fuel your amazing Idaho adventure!
Photo Credit: J S
Crusty’s is a vibey little place in downtown McCall, specializing in thin crust, New York style pizza. The Italian Pizza is absolutely to die for, loaded with Italian sausage, red peppers, and onion. But don’t overlook other heavy hitters on the menu, as Crusty’s makes one of the meanest BBQ chicken pizzas in the Rocky Mountains.
On top of great food, on most summer nights, talented live music graces the patio for your listening pleasure. Outdoor seating is available for those who want to breathe mountain air while enjoying a slice!
Photo Credit: J S
Hometown has been in business serving delicious pizza to locals and tourists alike for over 25 years. They started as a simple take-and-bake pizza joint and have remained true to their roots ever since. Today, you can still get takeout and bake it yourself or dine in.
Pizza isn’t the only lure to Hometown, as they also have a great selection of appetizers like delicious chicken wings and tasty sandwiches. The Buffalo Chicken Sandwich is a hot item on the menu in many different ways, so don’t be afraid to get spicy!
Don’t forget to grab a refreshment at the pub before you leave. The pub has a wide selection of brews and other adult beverages, and three of their on-tap beers are from small local breweries. Wine and even an apple cider margarita are also must tries.
Photo Credit: Ben Compton
Encircled by massive pine trees, the Toll Station is a beautiful place to grab a slice. Here, you can design your own pizza just how you like or grab a made-to-order pizza instead. Choice toppings include fresh parmesan and mozzarella cheese, jalapenos, Roma tomatoes, pesto, and classic pepperoni, to name a few.
Salads and soups are also the name of the game in the Toll Station. Delicious and refreshing choices such as their signature raspberry chicken salad make the mouth water just reading the menu! Crazy-good Caesar salads and wonderful Cobb salads covered in blue cheese crumbles are available.
These veggie delights are really to die for! But it doesn’t stop there. Soups are made in-house every day, so don’t be afraid to ask what soupy delights they are serving when you visit this flavor factory!
Photo Credit: Bryan Allen
Nestled inside a historic train station, The Salmon River Brewery is one of Idaho’s most unique pizza restaurants. It features a multitude of award-winning in-house brews that pair beautifully with your choice of delicious cuisine. Everybody can find something they like here with tons of scrumptious pub food. From burgers to paninis, and of course, pizza!
The taphouse is the establishment’s crown jewel. It showcases the refreshing products of its massive in-house brewery for you to taste! Here, you can enjoy a hometown brew in a friendly atmosphere, with views of the grand Rockies out your window!
Photo Credit: Lee Lbs
Named for the belle-of-the-ball Miss Kitty from the popular western TV show Gunsmoke, this pizza parlor has everything you could want in a Wild West experience! This out-of-town excursion, situated just west of McCall, is well worth the journey. Here, you can enthrall yourself in a wild west atmosphere while chowing down on pizzas named for the quickest guns in the West, like Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. Grab some delicious ice cream as well!
McCall is home to a wide variety of other foods if you’re not in the mood for pizza! The quaint little town has something for even the pickiest of eaters. Dive into something gourmet!
Photo Credit: Lior Alafi
The Cutwater is the most prestigious eatery in all of McCall. Featuring breakfast, lunch, and dinner, it boasts delicious, hand-crafted dishes for the whole family. If you are looking for a nice night out or a top-shelf breakfast, The Cutwater is the place to be!
The Cutwater sits directly on Payette Lake’s shores and has claimed one of the best views of any restaurant in McCall. Enjoying a fine glass of wine with an exquisite meal and stunning mountain scenery is a lovely way to spend time in McCall.
Photo Credit: Theodora Letz
The Brunchette on the Lake is a cozy little brunch joint in downtown McCall. Here, you can find beautifully roasted coffee, healthy breakfast foods, and gluten-free options for your favorite meals! Delicious, freshly squeezed orange juice is also available here, and it is sure to start your morning (or mid-morning) right.
McCall has cemented itself in the Rockies as a must-visit destination for any lover of wilderness, travel, or food! When you visit this quaint Idaho town, you are sure to end each evening with a full belly from delicious food, sore legs from hiking the trails, and a view like none other from your cozy McCall vacation rental. Get out there as soon as you can, as an adventure and delicious discoveries await you in McCall, Idaho!
