A Guide To The Best Restaurants in McCall, Idaho
Find great places to eat and dine on your Idaho visit!
In the nucleus of small-town America lies McCall, Idaho. Nestled among the pines at 5000 feet and along the shores of Payette Lake, awaits some of the best eating you’re likely to find in the state.
While you might think you won’t have many options in this small town, what they might lack in quantity, they definitely make up for in quality. Additionally, many restaurants offer breakfast, making it easy for visitors to enjoy delicious meals throughout the day without having to rely on their own cooking.
Most of McCall’s welcoming restaurants are perfect for meeting up with friends and enjoying good company. Several high-end eateries are great places to celebrate special occasions or gatherings.
You can even make eating out a little more fun and guilt-free by biking from location to location.
Whether you want to dine in or grab takeout to eat in the comfort of your vacation rental home, we’re sure you’ll love the restaurants on this list. Choose from a variety of dining experiences, from casual to fine dining, Mexican to Japanese, bakeries to all-American eats.
Without further ado, here are the best restaurants in McCall, Idaho that you need to visit.
Photo Credit: Julie208
Hometown Pizza has phenomenal grub. They make their own dough in-house every day using a tried and true recipe that hasn’t changed for decades. Hometown is a relaxed and cheery spot offering various pizzas, including take-and-bake options, along with beer and wine.
Broken Horn Brewing Company brews a seriously good beer. All beer is crafted on the premises and is available to go. A variety of craft beers is available on tap for guests to enjoy. Although Broken Horn itself doesn’t serve food from its bar, there’s a food truck out front that’s renowned for its tasty burgers, and you’re welcome to enjoy food inside or on the outdoor patio along with your beer.
Photo Credit: Xan
Evening Rise Bread Co. is an often-overlooked little hole-in-the-wall that has outstanding sandwiches. Their bread is freshly baked each day, and each sandwich is packed with high-quality ingredients. This is the perfect spot to grab a quick lunch.
Frenchies on Third has ridiculously good food. Think all-American classics, such as chowder, gumbo, pot roast, and shrimp po boys, only cooked to perfection usingf the highest quality ingredients. Ideal for a special meal, and a wonderful place to celebrate milestones or memorable occasions.
Photo Credit: Brent Hofacker
Enjoy fine dining in a casual mountain atmosphere. Prime rib, steaks, barbecue, and seafood are served in a space decorated with antiques and Western flair.
Growler’s Pizza Grill offers creative pizzas, burgers, and comfort food in a rustic space with warm interiors. A staple for traditional American eats.
Photo Credit: Carey Jaman
Stax serves delicious homemade soups and sandwiches at reasonable prices. A reliable, low-key stop for travelers and locals alike.
KBs serves up tasty burritos, tacos, chimichangas, and salads with fast and friendly service in a casual setting. It’s not just the go-to spot for lunch either.
This casual Mexican eatery serves breakfast burritos, with fillings like egg, steak, and chorizo. They even offer a gluten‑free version. It’s popular for grab-and-go morning flavor with Idaho residents.
Photo Credit: Brent Hofacker
This chill brewpub serves handcrafted ales alongside gourmet burgers and pub fare. Each ale is brewed with time and care to ensure maximum flavor. TVs are usually tuned to sports making this a great spot for game day.
This nostalgic burger joint is wildly popular among locals and tourists. Enjoy delicious charbroiled burgers, fries, ice cream sundaes, and milkshakes in a retro setting with outdoor seating.
Photo Credit: Lanista
A family-friendly brewery offering local beer, a rooftop patio with stunning views in summer, and a cozy fire pit in winter. The varied menu includes sharing platters, refreshing salads, yummy bowls, and pizzas.
Rupert’s delivers exceptional gourmet fare influenced by Mediterranean, Asian, and Southwestern cuisines. The menu changes with the season to make use of local produce. Enjoy indoor or patio dining and views of Payette Lake that are especially pretty if you happen to be visiting Idaho in the summer.
Photo Credit: carlos castilla
Lago Chapala is known for hearty Mexican meals and a laid-back atmosphere. Its patio offers greay views way out over Payette Lake, making it perfect for a sunny day and a filling lunch or dinner with friends.
Steamers delivers steaks, seafood, and wine in a charming space with an Old West vibe and rustic décor.
Photo Credit: FreshFocus
Known for hand-prepared sourdough pizzas, fresh ingredients, and a friendly atmosphere. Live music is often part of the experience.
One of McCall’s best-kept secrets, Stacey Cakes is a cozy artisan bakery known for its handcrafted pastries, pies, and cookies. Sometimes they also dish up savory items like soup and vegetable tarts.
Using quality, locally sourced ingredients, Stacey Cakes offers delicious baked goods and light meals perfect for any time of day. With its warm atmosphere and friendly service, Stacey Cakes is a favorite spot for both locals and visitors.
Photo Credit: pitviper007
Located in Shore Lodge on Payette Lake, The Cutwater pairs upscale cuisine with stunning lake views. It’s the ideal venue for a brunch, lunch, or dinner with ambiance. This place makes for a great evening if you have something to celebrate.
Steaks, burgers, and casual fare served in a classic saloon-style setting with a laid-back, rustic vibe.
Known for hearty portions and reliable satisfaction, this spot is perfect for unwinding after exploring Idaho’s outdoors or gathering with friends for a casual meal. Friendly service and a cozy atmosphere make it a favorite in McCall.
Photo Credit: pamungkas789
The Sushi Bar is a modern Japanese restaurant that serves high-quality sushi and other popular Asian dishes, such as pho and tom kha.
This is certainly the best place in town to satisfy your cravings for your favorite Asian meal. Even if you’re not a fan of sushi, you’ll find something great to enjoy here.
A local favorite for generous portions, bold flavors, and a festive dining atmosphere. Pueblo Lindo is ideal for family meals or a casual night out. You can never go wrong with Mexican cuisine, and the dishes here are loved for their authenticity.
The food in McCall is exceptional because restaurants across the city focus on fresh, locally sourced produce and craft beverages, creating memorable dining experiences that perfectly complement the town’s welcoming and adventurous spirit. Eat at any of these establishments and you certainly won’t be disappointed.
If you’re looking for the perfect base from which to explore McCall’s culinary scene, be sure to check out our luxurious vacation rentals and cabins for an incredible Idaho vacation.
Hero image by: Greerascris
